Making the Shift from 1099 to W-2: A Comprehensive Guide for Staffing Companies

Many staffing companies with gig, shift, and temporary workers start with a 1099 independent contractor workforce due to perceived cost savings and flexibility. Over the past decade companies like Bluecrew, Wonolo, Qwick, and others have shown that shifting to a W-2 model offers greater compliance, worker retention, and growth opportunities.

In this guide we’ll explore worker classifications, the business benefits behind classifying workers as employees, and how to make the shift from 1099 workers to W-2 employees. If you’re a leader at a staffing company that is looking to improve your business and grow, this guide is for you.

‍

What’s The Difference Between 1099 and W-2?

When staffing companies place workers, they must classify them correctly as 1099 independent contractors or W-2 employees. The right classification affects compliance, payroll, benefits, and overall business growth. 

To begin, let’s compare the two classifications: 

1099 Independent Contractors

Many companies prefer to classify workers as independent contractors because they don’t pay employer taxes, there’s less operational overhead, and the perception of increased flexibility. As 1099 workers are technically self-employed they typically: 

• Work on a project-by-project or short-term basis.
• Set their own hours and control how they complete work.
• Receive no tax withholdings or benefits from the employer.
• Are responsible for self-employment taxes (Social Security & Medicare)

1099 Risks for Staffing Companies 

• Misclassification penalties from the IRS and Department of Labor.
• Some states, like California, have stricter laws (AB5) making it harder to use 1099 workers.
• Delayed pay & tax issues can create worker dissatisfaction.
• Little incentive for workers to return for more job opportunities.

W-2 Employees

Staffing companies who classify their workers as W-2 employees have more control and responsibility. They are required by law to pay taxes, provide benefits, meet compliance obligations and more. However, they are also much less likely to have compliance violations and the workers are generally happier and have higher retention. In a W-2 model the workers typically:

• Follow assigned schedules and job duties set by the employer.
• Have taxes withheld automatically by the employer.
• May receive benefits like healthcare, workers’ comp, and unemployment insurance.

Are protected by labor laws, reducing compliance risks.

‍

6 Reasons to Expand to W-2 Employment 

1. Compliance and Risk Reduction - Stay compliant and avoid costly legal issues. Labor laws at the federal and state levels such as California’s AB5 are leaving staffing companies at a higher risk for audits and penalties for workers that are misclassified. Moving to a W-2 model eliminates the gray area and ensures you’re aligned with employment regulations, reducing the risk of fines and back-pay settlements.‍
2. Better Worker Experience - W-2 employees receive consistent pay, tax withholding, and eligibility for benefits, increasing their worker satisfaction and making them more likely to stay with your company.‍
3. Access New Customers - Many enterprise clients require W-2 workers for security and compliance reasons. By offering W-2 staffing, your company is better able to acquire larger and more diverse clientele than is possible with a 1099 model. ‍
4. Premium Services Offerings - W-2 workers provide staffing agencies and their clients with a more reliable, engaged, and productive workforce. Unlike 1099 workers, W-2 employees are eligible for overtime pay, benefits, and legal protections, making them more likely to take on repeat assignments. With greater job stability, W-2 workers develop stronger skills, become more efficient, and offer higher quality service. Staffing agencies that offer W-2 employees position themselves as premium providers, capable of delivering top-tier talent and justifying higher fees.  ‍
5. New Revenue Streams - Payment solutions that generate revenue such as on-demand pay, paycards, and earned wage access (EWA), provide staffing companies with new ways to monetize worker payments while enhancing the worker experience. By integrating these financial services, you can diversify income streams, increase worker engagement, and strengthen your market position.‍
6. Improved Business Valuation - Investors and buyers see W-2 based staffing businesses as more stable and scalable in comparison to 1099. This is because W-2 workforces produce more predictable revenue, reduced legal risks, and higher client retention rates making them more suited for long-term growth and investments. 

‍

How to Transition from 1099 to W-2

Step 1: Assess Your Current Workforce and Risk Exposure 

• Conduct an internal audit to determine how many of your 1099 workers should be reclassified. To do this: 
  
  • Review job responsibilities: Compare worker roles against IRS and Department of Labor guidelines to identify those who should be classified as W-2 employees. If a worker follows company-set schedules, receives training, or performs work central to your business, they may need reclassification.
  • Analyze work duration and control: Workers with long-term assignments or those subject to direct supervision are more likely to be considered employees rather than independent contractors.
  • Examine payment structures: If workers are paid hourly, weekly, or biweekly rather than per project, they may fit the W-2 model.
  • Check state and local regulations: Some states, like California (AB5), have stricter worker classification laws that could impact your workforce structure.
  • Consult legal and HR experts: Work with compliance specialists to ensure alignment with labor laws and avoid potential penalties.
• Check if workers meet IRS guidelines for independent contractors
• Identify which clients require W-2 workers and plan for compliance changes.

Step 2: Develop a W-2 Payroll Strategy

• Decide on payroll frequency (weekly, biweekly, etc.)
• Account for tax obligations: As an employer, staffing companies must contribute Social Security, Medicare, federal and state unemployment taxes (FUTA and SUTA). Understanding these tax obligations and ensuring correct withholdings are key to maintaining compliance and preventing penalties.
• Determine benefits strategy: Decide which benefits—such as health insurance, 401(k) plans, or paid time off—will be offered to W-2 workers. Use Zeal APIs to manage enrollments and deductions seamlessly. 
• Choose a trusted payroll provider that can handle the specific needs of staffing companies. You’ll want a payroll solution that works for the dynamic work arrangements commonly found in staffing. For example, workers that work across local and state jurisdictions will have complex tax withholding needs. You’ll also want a provider with scalable infrastructure, ensuring efficient payroll processing during high-volume staffing periods. 

Why legacy payroll providers aren’t built for staffing

Because traditional payroll systems are often designed for fixed, full-time employment, staffing agencies can find them rigid and ill-suited for the dynamic, high-turnover nature of staffing companies. Legacy providers also struggle with complex payroll cycles, varying worker classifications, and multi-location tax compliance. Finally, legacy providers are unable to keep pace with the expectations of employees who want fast and flexible ways to access their earnings. 

Step 3: Update Worker Agreements & Onboarding Processes

• Revise Employment Agreements: Ensure contracts reflect the shift from independent contractor to W-2 employee status. Update language to include tax withholdings, benefits eligibility, wage structure, and any applicable labor law requirements. Clearly outline expectations, responsibilities, and work conditions.‍
• Develop a Transparent Communication Plan: Inform workers about the transition early and explain how it benefits them. Highlight stability, access to benefits, faster payments, and legal protections they gain as W-2 employees. Provide clear documentation and FAQs to address concerns.‍
• Streamline Worker Onboarding: W-2 employees have a more involved onboarding process than 1099 workers. You’ll need to collect signed tax documents, complete I-9 employment verification, benefits enrollment, and more. You’ll also need to make sure that you are keeping employees information updated and accurate to ensure accurate tax withholding and compliance. Automation reduces manual administrative tasks and ensures compliance with labor laws.

Ensure Compliance with Federal and State Regulations: Review requirements for employment eligibility verification (I-9), background checks, and industry-specific certifications and compliance needs. Automating this process helps agencies stay compliant while reducing onboarding delays.

A bill called the Mandatory E-Verify Act of 2024 has been introduced that would require all employers to implement E-Verify employment verification for all workers, including 1099 contractors and W-2 employees. This bill also proposes increasing the penalties for violations of employment or paperwork requirements. Current Vice President JD Vance was a sponsor of the bill.

• Seamlessly Integrate Onboarding with Payroll: Ensure that all worker data collected during onboarding is directly integrated into payroll processing. The transition from onboarding to pay is a large and constantly running data input process. Having an integrated system reduces redundancies, minimizes errors, and ensures smooth payroll execution from day one.‍
• Leverage White-Label Solutions: Use as white-label onboarding solution to maintain a consistent brand experience while providing modern onboarding process for workers. Using an unified onboarding solution allows you to avoid using multiple tools to complete the job, and creates a smoother experience for workers.

Step 4: Establish a Benefits & Compensation Structure

A well-structured benefits and compensation plan is crucial for attracting top talent, ensuring employee satisfaction, and maintaining compliance with labor laws. Given the unique nature of contingent, temp, and contract work, staffing companies must balance required benefits with flexible offerings to stay competitive in the marketplace.

Determining Required & Competitive Benefits

Employers must comply with mandatory benefits, including:

• Workers' compensation insurance
• Unemployment insurance
• Social Security contributions
• Healthcare insurance 
• Retirement savings 
• Paid time off 

To optimize benefits selection:

• Conduct industry benchmarking to ensure offerings are competitive.
• Use employee surveys and feedback tools like CultureAmp or SurveyMonkey to understand workforce preferences.
• Implement a digital benefits administration system to streamline enrollments and compliance tracking.

Selecting a Benefits Administration Platform

Managing benefits manually can be complex and time-consuming. Choosing the right benefits administration platform streamlines this process by automating enrollments, deductions, and compliance tracking. Some platforms have robust benefits offerings while others focus on helping you meet the requirements cost efficiently. Consider which solution you need to  easily manage benefits and ensure employees have easy access to important information.

Best practices for benefits management include:

• Providing an employee self-service portal where workers can manage their benefits.
• Automating compliance tracking to meet local and federal benefits regulations.

Customizing Compensation Structures

Staffing companies must create compensation models that align with client needs, worker expectations, and compliance laws. Considerations include:

• Competitive wages to secure a worker for the opening.
• Hourly vs. salaried pay based on contract terms.
• Commission structures for specialized roles such as sales or recruiters.
• Performance incentives to reward tenure, shift fulfillment, and referrals.
• Legal compliance with minimum wage and overtime pay regulations.
• Markup and margin requirements to ensure your operating profitably.

To ensure fair pay practices and market competitiveness:

• Use compensation management software like PayScale or Workday.
• Conduct regular pay audits to stay competitive and compliant.
• Clearly define pay structures and communicate them to workers during onboarding.

Providing Payroll Flexibility & Financial Perks

Workers increasingly value pay flexibility. Staffing companies can improve payroll offerings by implementing:

• On-demand pay options so workers can access earnings before payday. 
• Instant pay to allow workers to get paid the same day they work and incentivize retention. 
• Paycards and digital wallets for convenient access to pay, especially for workers who don’t use traditional banks. 

To enhance financial wellness:

• Educate employees on how to leverage payroll flexibility.
• Ensure payroll systems integrate seamlessly with accounting software.

Ensuring Compliance with Wage & Hour Laws

Staying updated on wage and hour laws is critical for mitigating compliance risks. Employers should:

• Regularly monitor federal, state, and local minimum wage laws.
• Automate compliance tracking.
• Conduct routine audits to verify adherence to labor laws.

Educating Workers on Their Benefits

A benefits package is only effective if employees understand and use it. To improve communication:

• Offer clear, accessible benefits guides.
• Provide self-service tools for benefits management.
• Use webinars and training sessions to educate employees about their options.
• Make materials available in multiple languages to serve a diverse workforce.

Managing State-Mandated Retirement Plans

Many states require businesses to offer a retirement savings plan or allow employees to enroll in state-sponsored retirement programs. Employers must:

• Stay informed about state-mandated retirement plan requirements.
• Automate compliance and enrollment using Guideline or Betterment for Business.
• Regularly monitor legislative updates via the U.S. Department of Labor.

Step 5: Automate Employment Compliance

Automating employment compliance is essential for staffing companies to reduce administrative burden, minimize errors, and avoid penalties. Leveraging modern payroll technology and compliance tools can help streamline these processes, allowing staffing companies to focus on scaling their business and improving worker satisfaction.

Essential Payroll & Compliance Automation Features

To effectively manage payroll and compliance, staffing companies should implement tools that offer:

• Gross-to-net Calculations: Accurately calculating gross pay, deductions, and net pay, automatically, regardless of the complexity of the work arrangement.
• W-2 and 1099 Processing – Automate the generation and delivery of year-end tax forms to employees and contractors, ensuring compliance with IRS deadlines.
• Automated Tax Filings – Use payroll software that handles all federal, state, and local tax withholdings and filings to prevent errors and penalties.
• Wage & Hour Compliance – Track and enforce compliance with wage laws, overtime regulations, and other labor requirements that vary by state.
• Flexible Payroll Options – Offer same-day, instant pay, paycards, and earned wage access (EWA) to provide workers with financial flexibility.
• Integrated Benefits Deductions – Ensure payroll deductions for health insurance, 401(k), and other benefits are automated and accurate.
• New Hire Reporting – Use HR software that automates new hire reporting to meet state-mandated compliance requirements.
• Multi-Jurisdiction Payroll Processing – Adopt a system that supports tax compliance and accurate payroll calculations across different states.
• Garnishment & Wage Attachments – Automate deductions for child support, garnishments, and other legal orders to ensure accuracy and compliance.
• Payroll Error Detection – Leverage AI-powered solutions to identify and correct payroll errors before processing to reduce financial discrepancies.
• Real-Time Payroll & Tax Reporting – Implement accurate payroll previews and live reporting dashboards to monitor payroll activities and conduct compliance audits efficiently.
• Meal & Rest Break Compliance – Use software that tracks meal and rest break timestamps to ensure compliance with state laws. Staffing companies can apply universal policies or create state-specific templates.
• Tax Jurisdiction Tracking – Choose a system that proactively alerts you when a new tax registration is required based on updates to your employees home or clients work locations.
• Tax Registrations - Use tax registration management tools like Middesk to ensure compliance as businesses expand into new locations.
• Custom API Integrations – Select payroll solutions that integrate seamlessly with applicant tracking, time tracking, and workforce management systems for smooth operations.‍
• Paid Time Off (PTO) and Paid Sick Management – Automate accrual and tracking of PTO to ensure compliance with company policies and state regulations.

Step 6: Communicate with Clients & Workers

Transitioning from a 1099 to W-2 workforce presents a valuable opportunity to strengthen client relationships and position your company for sustainable growth. Effective communication is key to ensuring a smooth transition for both clients and workers.

• Educate Clients on Compliance Benefits – Many enterprise clients require W-2 employees due to compliance concerns. Clearly outline the legal advantages, reduced misclassification risks, and streamlined workforce management that W-2 staffing provides.
• Showcase Improved Worker Experience – Emphasize the benefits of W-2 employment, including faster pay, benefits eligibility, and financial stability. Clients will appreciate how this leads to increased worker efficiency, satisfaction, reliability, and retention.
• Leverage Payroll & Compliance Tools – Demonstrate how automated tax filings, instant pay options, and compliance management reduce administrative burdens and ensure seamless payroll processing.
• Expand Service Offerings – Acting as the employer allows staffing companies to provide value-added services such as payroll financing, benefits administration, and tax compliance management, opening new revenue streams.
• Ensure a Seamless Transition – Work closely with clients to align expectations, address concerns, and implement W-2 employment gradually. Offer detailed transition plans and continuous support to reinforce trust and confidence. 

Informing and Educating Workers 

Transitioning workers from 1099 contractor status to W-2 employment is a big change. Clear communication will be key to maintaining stability and productivity. You should expect that workers will have concerns about how their pay, benefits, and taxes will be affected. Focus on explaining the advantages of W-2 employment, framing the change as a chance for workers to gain greater stability and financial security. 

• Highlight the Stability and Benefits - Explain that as W-2 employees, workers now gain access to benefits such as healthcare insurance, paid time off, retirement plans, and overtime pay. Unlike 1099 workers, they are guaranteed rights to minimum wage protection and worker’s compensation.
• Provide Clarity Around Tax Withholding and Compliance - Inform workers that as W-2 employees, their taxes will now be withheld automatically, covering Social Security, Medicare, and income taxes. This means fewer compliance headaches for them come tax season. 
• Prioritize Support and Transparency - Consider offering one-on-one support and consultation, invest in training on how the change impacts pay, benefits, and workplace protections. 

By positioning your company as a compliant, worker-friendly, and tech-enabled staffing provider, you not only retain clients but also attract new business opportunities.

‍

How Zeal Helps Staffing Companies Transition from 1099 to W-2

Transitioning from a 1099 to W-2 workforce can be complex, but with the right technology and expertise, staffing companies can ensure a smooth and compliant process. Zeal offers a payroll and compliance infrastructure designed specifically for staffing companies, providing the necessary tools to manage high-volume payroll needs, automate compliance, and unlock new revenue streams.

1. Automated Compliance & Risk Management

Zeal simplifies compliance by handling tax withholdings, onboarding, benefits, and reporting requirements.

• Automated Tax Withholding & Filings: Zeal ensures accurate and timely tax filings for federal, state, and local jurisdictions, eliminating the risk of penalties for misclassification.
• Multi-State Compliance Management: Zeal’s system adapts to changing labor laws, minimum wage updates, overtime pay changes, and paid sick leave policies, helping staffing companies stay ahead of evolving regulations.
• Employment Eligibility & Verification: Zeal integrates with E-Verify and automated onboarding tools to streamline hiring and ensure full compliance with worker classification laws.

2. Flexible Payroll Solutions for Staffing Companies

Zeal’s payroll infrastructure is built to be flexible to handle any work arrangement and  seamlessly execute payroll execution even during peak hiring seasons.

• Flexible Payroll Processing: Supports instant, daily, weekly, biweekly, semi-monthly, and monthly payroll cycles, catering to both W-2 and 1099 workers.
• Seamless ATS & Timekeeping Integration: Zeal connects with applicant tracking systems (ATS) and workforce management tools to ensure payroll is automatically processed based on approved work hours.
• Gross-to-net Calculations: Automates calculating gross pay, all deductions including taxes, wage garnishments, 401(k) contributions, and healthcare deductions, reducing administrative workload.

3. Enhanced Worker Experience & Retention

A W-2 workforce benefits from increased financial security and consistency, leading to improved worker retention. Zeal helps staffing companies offer:

• Instant & On-Demand Pay: Workers can access earned wages immediately instead of waiting for traditional pay cycles, reducing financial stress and increasing job satisfaction.
• Paycards: Paycards and Digital Wallets ensure that all workers, including those without bank accounts, can access their wages efficiently.
• White-Label Mobile App: In minutes, without code, staffing companies can provide a custom branded, seamless pay, payroll, and benefits experience through Zeal’s white-labelled mobile app. 

Ready to scale your staffing business with a W-2 workforce? Contact Zeal today to learn how we can help you make the shift from 1099 to W-2 easily!

‍